1 Shares

Grilled Reuben Dogs are a creative and indulgent twist on two beloved comfort foods: the classic Reuben sandwich and the all-American hot dog. At first glance, they might sound like a quirky mash-up, but once you take that first bite, the flavors prove how perfectly they belong together. Imagine the juicy snap of a grilled frankfurter nestled in a toasted bun, immediately followed by a blanket of melted Swiss cheese, ribbons of savory pastrami, tangy sauerkraut, refreshing cucumber pickles, and a drizzle of creamy, tangy fry sauce. It’s a bold reimagining that respects tradition while embracing playful creativity. Unlike a heavy sandwich or a plain hot dog, these Reuben Dogs strike an enjoyable balance—hearty and filling, yet layered with enough freshness and acidity to keep you wanting another bite. Perfect for outdoor grilling sessions, casual family dinners, or even tailgate parties, this recipe showcases how you can take a familiar idea and elevate it into something fun, memorable, and utterly satisfying.

Full Recipe:

Ingredients

Hot dogs (preferably high-quality, like grass-fed beef)
Buns, toasted if desired
Slices of Swiss cheese
Thinly sliced deli pastrami
Sauerkraut
Marinated cucumber ribbons (English cucumber, vinegar, water, salt, pepper)
Fry sauce (mayo, ketchup, a splash of cucumber vinegar, seasoning)

Directions

Preheat the grill to medium heat.
Grill the hot dogs until evenly browned and heated through, turning them for an even char.
Lightly toast the buns on the grill for added structure and flavor.
Place each hot dog inside a toasted bun.
While the hot dogs are still hot, layer slices of Swiss cheese over them so the heat gently melts the cheese.
Add thin slices of pastrami on top of the cheese.
Spoon sauerkraut generously over the pastrami.
Layer marinated cucumber ribbons for crispness and a refreshing contrast.
Drizzle fry sauce over the toppings just before serving.
Serve immediately while warm.

Nutrients

Swiss cheese: provides calcium, protein, and vitamin B12
Pastrami: good source of protein and iron, though higher in sodium
Sauerkraut: rich in probiotics, vitamin C, and fiber
Cucumbers: low-calorie, hydrating, adds a crisp texture
Fry sauce components: mayo and ketchup add fats and flavor; vinegar adds tang

Why This Recipe Stands Out

What makes Grilled Reuben Dogs so special is their unique ability to transform two classics into one cohesive dish. On their own, hot dogs are a timeless cookout staple, while the Reuben sandwich is celebrated for its robust flavors and deli heritage. By combining the two, you get the comfort and familiarity of both in a way that feels fresh and new. It’s playful enough for a weekend barbecue yet sophisticated enough to serve at casual dinner parties. The layering of flavors is thoughtfully designed: smoky, juicy hot dogs form the foundation; Swiss cheese adds creaminess and depth; pastrami layers in richness; sauerkraut delivers tang and probiotics; cucumber ribbons lend crunch and brightness; and fry sauce ties everything together with its silky, tangy balance. Each bite tells a story of contrasting yet complementary textures and flavors. Beyond taste, this recipe is also about the experience—it’s portable, easy to customize, and just plain fun to eat. That’s why it stands out: it delivers comfort, creativity, and crowd-pleasing appeal all at once.

The Benefits of the Ingredients

The ingredients in this recipe don’t just add flavor—they bring balance and nutritional value as well. Choosing high-quality hot dogs, particularly those made from grass-fed beef, ensures better flavor and fewer additives compared to cheaper varieties. Swiss cheese not only provides the gooey melt factor but also offers protein, calcium, and vitamin B12, all important for bone health and energy. Pastrami, though indulgent, contributes iron and protein, making it hearty and satisfying. Sauerkraut is a nutritional powerhouse in disguise; its fermentation process yields probiotics that support gut health, while its vitamin C content helps boost immunity. Cucumbers may seem like a small addition, but they add freshness, hydration, and a low-calorie crunch that balances the richness of the meat and cheese. The fry sauce may be indulgent, but it plays a crucial role in flavor, bringing creamy tang and tying all the other components together. Altogether, this recipe reflects a balance of indulgence and nourishment—hearty enough to be comforting, yet punctuated with fresh and wholesome elements.

Cooking Tips

The secret to making the best Grilled Reuben Dogs lies in the details. When grilling hot dogs, medium heat is ideal—it gives them a smoky char without causing the casing to split or the inside to dry out. Toasting the buns adds structure and helps them hold up against the juicy toppings. For the cheese, timing is everything: place it on the hot dogs while they’re still warm so the residual heat gently melts it into the bun. The pastrami works best when thinly sliced so it layers easily without overwhelming the dog. Marinating cucumber ribbons in vinegar for at least fifteen minutes ensures they soak up enough tanginess to stand out but still maintain their crunch. Sauerkraut can be used straight from the jar, but draining excess liquid prevents soggy buns. Fry sauce should be drizzled right before serving so it doesn’t soak into the bread too early. For larger gatherings, consider setting up a DIY station with toppings so guests can build their own Reuben Dogs to taste—this not only makes entertaining easier but also adds an interactive element to your meal.

Serving Suggestions

Reuben Dogs pair wonderfully with a range of sides, making them versatile for different occasions. For a classic barbecue spread, serve them with kettle-cooked chips, dill pickles, or crunchy coleslaw to provide contrast and freshness. If you’re looking for something more substantial, baked potato wedges or seasoned fries make hearty accompaniments. To lighten the meal, pair them with a crisp green salad dressed with lemon vinaigrette, balancing the richness of the hot dogs. For spice lovers, keep condiments like spicy mustard, horseradish cream, or hot pepper relish on hand as optional drizzles. Beverages can also play a big role in the experience: cold craft beers, tangy lemonade, or iced tea pair beautifully with the smoky, tangy flavors of the dish. Families with children might enjoy preparing smaller versions using slider buns—perfectly portioned for little hands and fun to eat when served with carrot sticks or apple slices on the side. No matter the occasion, Reuben Dogs adapt seamlessly, becoming either a hearty main course or a playful party centerpiece.

Conclusion

Grilled Reuben Dogs are more than just a recipe; they are a celebration of how food traditions can be reinvented while still honoring their roots. By combining the deli-inspired flavors of a Reuben sandwich with the laid-back charm of a grilled hot dog, you create a dish that is simultaneously comforting, exciting, and approachable. The juiciness of the sausage, the creaminess of Swiss cheese, the salty depth of pastrami, the tang of sauerkraut, the refreshing crunch of cucumbers, and the luscious drizzle of fry sauce all work together in perfect harmony. This dish doesn’t just fill your stomach—it brings people together, sparks conversation, and adds fun to the dining table. Whether served at a backyard cookout, a casual weeknight dinner, or even as a novelty item at a party, these Reuben Dogs deliver flavor and joy in equal measure. They remind us that the best meals aren’t just about eating—they’re about sharing moments, indulging in creativity, and savoring the playful spirit of cooking.

Pin1